FRN / The Atlas / Front Range Bentonite
The Atlas · Region 03 · Colorado

Where the bedrock stands on end.

Along the foot of the Rockies, clay made from ancient volcanic ash swells with every drop of water it finds. In places the mountains tilted that clay up on edge, and the ground heaves in long ridges you can feel through a car.

Region Denver · Colorado Springs · Fort CollinsSources Colorado Geological Survey · USGS · ASCEReading time 10 min
15xVolume pure montmorillonite can reach when wet
30,000psf swell pressure the clay can exert
28 inHeight of measured bedrock heave ridges
1,067 mLength a single heave ridge can run
$2.3BYearly U.S. swelling soil damage, 1973 estimate
14 daysBefore closing, Colorado buyers get the soils report

Drive south on C-470 near Bowles Avenue and Wadsworth Boulevard in the Denver suburbs and the road starts to ripple. It is not bad paving. The highway crosses layers of clay-rich bedrock that the rising Rockies tilted up on edge, and each layer swells by a different amount when water reaches it. The ground under the road is heaving in stripes.

The Colorado Geological Survey has called swelling soil the state’s most significant geologic hazard. It does not arrive with a storm. It works quietly, season after season, under houses, schools and highways from Fort Collins to Colorado Springs.

This is the Front Range: some of the most aggressive swelling ground in North America, and a place where the way a house is founded decides whether it lasts.

01
Chapter One · The Clay

Volcanic ash that drinks.

The swelling clay under the Front Range began as volcanic ash. Weathered, it became montmorillonite, the mineral in bentonite, and montmorillonite pulls water into its own structure.

DRYCLAY PLATELETS PACKED TIGHT+ WATERWET: WATER WEDGES BETWEEN LAYERSSWELLMONTMORILLONITE (BENTONITE)SCHEMATIC. REAL PLATELETS ARE NANOMETERS THICK.
Fig. 1 How clay swellsIllustrative section. Not to scale.

Each grain of montmorillonite is a stack of thin sheets. Water slips in between the sheets and pushes them apart. According to the Colorado Geological Survey, pure montmorillonite can expand up to 15 times its original volume. Natural soils are mixtures and rarely swell beyond about one and a half times their size, but engineers consider an increase of only 3 percent potentially damaging.

The force is the real problem. The Survey says swelling clay can push on foundations and slabs with pressures reaching 30,000 pounds per square foot. A house weighs nothing by comparison. On the eastern plains the culprits are the Denver-Dawson, Laramie and Pierre shales. On the Western Slope it is the Mancos and Lewis.

Colorado Geological Survey
15x
Pure montmorillonite, up to

The mineral

Natural soils rarely pass 1.5 times their size. Engineers flag 3 percent as potentially damaging.

Colorado Geological Survey
30,000
Pounds per square foot

The force

Swell pressure that can be exerted on foundations and slabs.

Holtz & Hart, CGS SP-11
4
Front Range shales named

The formations

Denver-Dawson, Laramie and Pierre on the plains. Mancos and Lewis on the Western Slope.

The lesson

A slab is not heavy enough to hold clay down. It has to be built so the clay cannot reach it.

02
Chapter Two · The Climate

Dry country makes clay dangerous.

Swelling needs two things: clay and a change in moisture. Colorado’s semi-arid climate keeps the clay dry and hungry, and then people bring the water.

SEMI-ARID: CLAY STARTS DRYLAWN IRRIGATIONWETTED CLAY SWELLSCORNER LIFTSDRY SIDE STAYS PUT
Fig. 2 Uneven wettingIllustrative section. Not to scale.

In a wet climate, clay stays close to saturated and has little room to swell. On the Front Range it spends most of its life dry. Build a house on it, plant a lawn, run the sprinklers, and the ground beside the foundation gets more water than it has seen in centuries. The Colorado Geological Survey’s 1978 guide to building on swelling soils names the semi-arid climate as one reason Colorado is among the most severely affected states, and notes that more than 90 percent of its people live on the eastern plains or in Western Slope valleys, right where these soils are common.

Shrinkage works the other way. The same guide warns that trees and shrubs can dry clay out near a foundation and pull support from under it. Damage often comes slowly, and houses on the same street can be hit years apart, depending on how each one has been watered, planted and drained.

Colorado’s most significant geologic hazard.Colorado Geological Survey, on swelling soils
The lesson

On swelling clay, water is a load. Where it goes decides where the house moves.

03
Chapter Three · Dipping Bedrock

The ground heaves in stripes.

Where the Rockies rose, they bent the sedimentary layers along their flank upward until some stand nearly vertical. Swelling claystone sits beside siltstone that barely moves.

ROAD RIPPLES OVER EACH CLAY BANDBEDROCK TILTED 30 DEGREES TO VERTICALCLAYSTONE SWELLSSILTSTONE DOES NOTHEAVE RIDGE
Fig. 3 Differential heaveIllustrative section. Not to scale.

Geologists Noe, Higgins and Olsen mapped what this does near Denver in a 2007 study. They describe Mesozoic bedrock tilted from about 30 degrees to vertical, even overturned, and claystone weathered and fractured to depths of roughly 64 to 73 feet. When water reaches it, each clay band swells while the layers beside it do not.

The result is a set of long, low ridges running parallel to the mountain front. The team measured heave features up to about 28 inches high, up to 58 meters wide and as long as 1,067 meters. They describe severe damage near the Denver metropolitan area. A house built across one of those bands gets lifted along a line, not evenly.

Local governments responded with maps and rules. Douglas County created a Dipping Bedrock Overlay District, Jefferson County regulates dipping bedrock areas, and the Colorado Geological Survey published a heave susceptibility map for Colorado Springs.

Noe, Higgins & Olsen, 2007
28 in
Heave ridge height, up to

Ridges

Linear to curvilinear, running parallel to the mountain front.

Noe, Higgins & Olsen, 2007
1,067 m
Ridge length, up to

Scale

Widths up to 58 m, with width to height ratios from 45:1 to 400:1.

Douglas & Jefferson Counties
Overlay
Dipping bedrock districts

Regulation

Mapped zones where building on heaving bedrock needs special investigation.

The lesson

On tilted bedrock, a house can be lifted along a line drawn right through the living room.

04
Chapter Four · The Cost

The quiet billion-dollar disaster.

Swelling soil rarely makes the news, because it never destroys a town in a day. It damages a few houses on every street, every year.

ANNUAL U.S. DAMAGE, JONES & HOLTZ, 1973EXPANSIVE SOILS: AT LEAST $2.3 BILLION A YEARFLOODS + HURRICANES + TORNADOES + EARTHQUAKESCOMBINED: LESS THAN HALFBAR LENGTHS SHOW THE RATIO REPORTED BY THE AUTHORS, NOT EXACT DOLLARS.
Fig. 4 The hidden disasterIllustrative section. Not to scale.

In 1973, engineers D. E. Jones Jr. and Wesley Holtz published an article in the American Society of Civil Engineers’ magazine titled “Expansive Soils: The Hidden Disaster.” They estimated that shrinking and swelling soils caused at least $2.3 billion a year in damage to American houses, buildings, roads and pipelines. That was more than twice the damage from floods, hurricanes, tornadoes and earthquakes combined.

The Colorado Geological Survey adds its own ledger: more than 250,000 new homes built on expansive soils each year nationally, about 60 percent with minor damage and about 10 percent with significant damage, some beyond repair. In eastern Colorado, up to a foot of uplift forced the repair of two interstate lanes only six months after they were paved.

Jones & Holtz, ASCE, 1973
$2.3B
Per year, at least

Nationwide

More than twice floods, hurricanes, tornadoes and earthquakes combined.

Colorado Geological Survey
10%
Of homes on expansive soil

Significant damage

Of 250,000 new homes a year, about 60 percent minor and 10 percent significant.

Colorado Geological Survey
1 ft
Highway uplift

Eastern Colorado

Two interstate lanes repaired only six months after paving.

The lesson

A disaster spread thin is still a disaster. It just arrives one house at a time.

05
Chapter Five · The Fix

Do not fight the clay. Go under it.

You cannot out-weigh swelling clay. The answer the Colorado Geological Survey has given homeowners for decades is to carry the building past it and leave the clay room to move.

STRUCTURAL FLOOR SPANS ABOVE THE CLAYGRADE BEAMVOID UNDER BEAMACTIVE ZONE: SWELLS AND SHRINKSBOTTOM OF SEASONAL MOISTURE CHANGEDRILLED PIERS ANCHORED BELOW
Fig. 5 Pier and grade beamIllustrative section. Not to scale.

The Survey’s guide for homeowners recommends drilled pier and grade beam foundations for moderately to highly swelling soils. The piers extend below the zone where seasonal moisture changes and are anchored in ground that does not swell. The grade beam spans between them with a 3 to 6 inch gap left beneath it, so the clay can swell into empty space instead of pushing on concrete. An ordinary slab on grade is not recommended on natural swelling soils.

Inside, the same logic continues. Structural floors span above the soil instead of resting on it. Where a floating slab is used, it is isolated from walls, columns and stairs, non-bearing walls can be hung with a gap above the floor, and utility lines get flexible connections so a moving slab does not tear them apart.

For an existing house that has already moved, the question is the same as anywhere: what is the mechanism, how deep is the active zone, and what does a support have to reach to get below it.

Colorado law · C.R.S. 6-6.5-101

Developers and builders selling a new home must give the buyer a summary of the site analysis and recommendations at least 14 days before closing. Where the site has significant potential for expansive soils, the buyer must also receive a publication explaining the problems they cause, construction methods and maintenance. The penalty for failing to provide them is $500, payable to the buyer.

For buyers

Read the soils report before you close. The Colorado Geological Survey’s guide for homebuyers, SP-43, was written in part to help satisfy the disclosure requirement and includes a property checklist. On an older home, ask what the foundation sits on and whether there is a structural floor.

The lesson

On the Front Range, the foundation type matters more than the floor plan.

Elsewhere in the Atlas

Same clay, different ground.

TX

Texas & Gulf Coast Clays

Houston Black and the 2011 drought. Shrink-swell on a giant scale.

AZ

Arizona & Desert Southwest

Collapsible soil that drops the first time it gets wet, and fissures from pumping.

FL

Florida Karst

Limestone dissolving under sand. Raveling, sinkholes and cover collapse.

SD

The Storm Desk

What hurricanes, droughts and earthquakes did to the ground under buildings.

Ask the Network

Is your house riding the clay?

Tell us what you are seeing, where the property is and how it is founded if you know. We read every message and reach back out.

Send a question →